IRRI-KIIB expert seminar:
“The Global Governance of the international
Migration: A Belgian Perspective”
Brussels, Egmont Palace, 12 June 2006
Concluding remarks
Mr. François Fouinat
United Nations
I would like to congratulate you for the initiative that was taken by the
Institute on this important topic.
Last week, the UN Secretary General presented his report on Migration and
Development in preparation of the High Level Dialogue of next September. Through
this document, the international community is asked to reflect in order to
improve the coherence of the activities in the field of migration and
development.
This report deals with a number of aspects. What really merits our attention
today is the follow-up that could be given to this High Level Dialogue. The SG
makes a proposal inviting governments to think of a consultative forum to debate
questions related to migration and development. How will this proposal be
received? Nobody knows, but we could look at the challenges and opportunities it
offers.
Actors in international migration, a part from migrants themselves, pertain to
two broad categories: governments on the one hand and international institutions
on the other. As far as the governments are concerned, what are the elements
that can help them to decide to accept or refuse the proposal made by the
Secretary-General? The main issue concerns the added value of the proposed
forum. This question has already been addressed by previous speakers, notably by
Dr. Rolf Jenny. It is for governments to evaluate the positive and less positive
aspects of this proposal. I would just add that, by establishing a forum under
the auspices of the UN, governments would benefit from the universality of the
organisation, as well as from its multi-disciplinary character, embracing the
multiple facets of modern migration.
For their part, international institutions are performing a very useful work in
the various areas of their competences and mandates. I regret , however, along
with comments made earlier, that cooperation between these institutions has not
reached a satisfactory level. The 12 international bodies (11 UN and IOM)
involved in the newly created Global Migration Group (GMG) are yet to organise
themselves to provide a coherent and comprehensive service to the international
community in the field of international migration. The establishment of a forum
of governments would no doubt constitute a strong encouragement for these
agencies to cooperate more closely and create much needed synergies between
their actions. It might also permit to strengthen a necessary and workable
interface between governments and international institutions on migration
issues.
Since the Cairo conference, international thinking has come a long way. Still,
the notion that governments could meet in one single place to discuss in a
non-binding manner issues, at time contentious, of international migration has
yet to come to fruition. The demarche leading to the forum is rooted in the
numerous initiatives that have been developed. Regional processes, in
particular, constitute a solid basis. They have proved that cooperation between
states can help address difficult situations. The proposed global forum
represents more than the sum of regional ones. It is time now to expand the
scope of cooperation to the global level in order to be able to address modern
migration trends.
The notion of forum is still undefined and does not correspond to any known
category within the UN. Governments will need to be ready to engage into
innovative approaches. In these efforts, they could benefit from the assistance
of the UN, particularly from the Special Representative of the
Secretary-General, Peter Sutherland, who has been at the origin of the proposal.
Of particular importance will be the definition of the link between the
state-run forum and the UN, as the forum should benefit from a UN umbrella
without getting entangled in cumbersome procedures. I hope that interested
governments will engage into this process, together with the UN, and identify
the most appropriate and creative solutions leading to an improved and more
comprehensive approach of migration issues.